Tag-Archive for » Hosea 4:6 «

For Whom the Bell Tolls (2)

Friday, February 25th, 2011 | Author:

My people are destroyed from lack of knowledge.  Because you have rejected knowledge I will reject you from priestly service for me.  You have forgotten the instruction of your God; so I too will forget your children. Hosea 4:6  (translation J. A. Dearman)

Forget – When you think of the Hebrew verb forget, think of Robert Frost, the American poet.  “Fences make good neighbors,” wrote Frost.  In Hebrew, shakah does much more than make good neighbors.  To forget is to tear down the fence that provides life.  The pictograph of Shin-Kaf-Chet is “what destroys the fence around the open palm.”  God fences us in on purpose.  The broken world is a dangerous and unhealthy place.  God protects with His instructions, often in ways that we cannot comprehend.  When we forget, we tear down the fence that keeps life and chaos apart.  When we forget, we let sin in.  When we forget, we open the door (as Paul says) and life tumbles.

You’ll say, “I haven’t forgotten the Lord.  I pray.  I read my Bible.  I am involved in a believing community.  God is real to me.”  Wait a minute.  Let’s step back and take a deeper look at this verse.  Of course, these are words of the prophet Hosea to Israel, so in the historical sense it isn’t written to us.  But the principle applies.  We can experience the destitution of silence if we reject the Way.  There is something here for us in spite of the fact that the words are thousands of years old.  Here is the principle: “measure for measure.”  Forgetting works both ways.  If we forget, God forgets.  Now look closely at what we are likely to forget (and what Israel is accused of forgetting).  Hosea doesn’t say, “You have forgotten Me!”  That would be a non sequitur.   If the people actually forgot God, then His words to them would be like hearing thunder in the distance.  Who knows what that means?  No, YHWH says, “You have forgotten My instructions!”  Now we have specificity.  Now we know exactly what has happened.  These people claim to follow YHWH but they do not do what YHWH tells them to do.  The bell tolls for them, not because they don’t have a “relationship” but because they don’t act according to the obligations of the relationship.  They have a “saving knowledge” but their lives are examples of sinful acts.  Consequently, they are forgotten.

We learn a very important linguistic (and spiritual) lesson here.  The opposite of forgetting is not remembering.  The opposite of forgetting is obeying.  In the cognitive world of Greek epistemology, forgetting is a mental state.  Therefore, its antonym is also a mental state.  In the Greek world, forget is the opposite of remember.  But in Hebraic metaphysics, forgetting is not about a mental condition.  It is about a moral failure.  To forget is to tear down the fence between chaos and life.  Forgetting is failing to bring something into action.  Forgetting is the failure to respond to the demands of the Lord.  It’s not mental.  It’s moral.

Now we can ask ourselves if we have forgotten God.  How?  By comparing our lives with the standard of His instructions.  Where we find a mismatch, forgetting should come to mind.  Check out the 613 for starters.  If you want to see the rest of the obligations, take a look here.  You might be surprised to find that there are more commands in the New Testament than there are in the Torah.  Then ask yourself if you are remembering or forgetting.

Topical Index:  forget, shakah, measure for measure, Hosea 4:6

For Whom the Bell Tolls (1)

Thursday, February 24th, 2011 | Author:

My people are destroyed from lack of knowledge.  Because you have rejected knowledge I will reject you from priestly service for me.  You have forgotten the instruction of your God; so I too will forget your children. Hosea 4:6  (translation J. A. Dearman)

Reject you – We feel good about the love story of Hosea.  In spite of Gomer’s unfaithfulness, Hosea redeems her and restores her.  As a metaphor for Israel, we rejoice that God’s faithfulness wins in the end.  But maybe we are too quick to rush to the conclusion.  Maybe the process of redemption is so painful, so full of risk and warning that we gloss over the terror in the text.  That would be a mistake.  All the words are God’s words.  So, sit down.  Take a deep breath and listen to the alarm.  The bell tolls for you and me.

Whom does God reject?  We could opt for the easy answer.  God rejects the false priests.  God rejects those who teach heresy or lead His people astray.  God rejects those who fail to act upon His instructions.  Of course, that’s not us.  We are the good people of God.  We can dismiss this verse.  It doesn’t apply.

But what if there is more in mind here?  What if God is rejecting the leaders of His people who reject His instruction and, as a result, God is also rejecting those who follow them?  Take one step back and ask yourself why God established Israel in the first place.  Didn’t God constitute Israel to be a royal priesthood to the nations?  Doesn’t that mean that everyone who claims to be called by His name but rejects His instruction is rejected as a priest to the nations?  It’s not just the leaders who are in the crosshairs.  We who claim to follow are also targets of God’s rejection.  We cannot be priests if our leaders do not remember (bring to mind for action) and we do not fulfill His instructions.

“I will reject you” (em-aska) encompasses both the leadership and the followers.  The root (ma’an) describes the refusal of an offer.  In pictograph, chaos confronts life – and wins.  God’s order is withdrawn.  Life devolves.  The people of God collectively stumble and fall.  No one escapes the consequences of a failure of leadership.  If you thought that your obedience would keep you safe in a community that fails to bring God’s instructions into action, be warned.  The bell tolls for you.

Why does God reject?  Hosea is a story of recovery.  Why would God pronounce rejection?  The answer is obvious: measure for measure.  The leaders reject God’s wisdom.  They refuse God’s offer of order.  The rejection might come as a result of forgetting or ignoring or rebellion.  It doesn’t matter.  Measure for measure.  The leaders bring the consequences upon themselves.  God refuses them.  The real tragedy is that the leaders carry the people.  They literally hold the welfare of the people in their hands.  Rejection of God’s ways has direct consequences on all the followers.  The people are rejected by God, not because they are immediately responsible, but because their leadership has failed.  No man can survive the judgment of God once he enlists in the service of leaders who reject the wisdom of the King.  I guess the important question is this:  Who am I following?

Topical Index:  reject, ma’an, measure for measure, Hosea 4:6

Just Think About It

Tuesday, December 16th, 2008 | Author:

My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge Hosea 4:6

Knowledge – How often have you heard this verse quoted in a plea for renewed diligence toward the things of God?  The quotation is usually followed by an enumeration of our lack of Bible study, church attendance, daily devotion or some other missing element in the quest to understand God’s ways.  But what if the verse doesn’t really say anything about our scarcity of divine information?  What if it’s about something that has nothing to do with mental cognition?  Would that change our actions?

This Hebrew word (da’at) comes from the word ‘yada.  Of course, ‘yada is not just about factual information.  It covers the range from knowing that 2+2=4 to Adam knowing Eve.  In its application to God, it’s not about information.  It’s about relationship in action.  Why are God’s people destroyed (actually, the word means “cut off”)?  It’s because they lack an intimate, working relationship with Him.  They have plenty of information, but they lack desire to apply it.  We would have seen this immediately if we had just continued to read the rest of the verse.  “Because you have rejected the knowledge, I also rejected you from being priest to Me.  Since you have forgotten the law of your God, I will forget your sons.”  What does it mean to lack knowledge?  It means to forget God’s instructions.  Knowledge of God is practical application of His Torah.  The people God rejects, the ones He forgets, are the ones who no longer practice His commandments.  They don’t lack systematic theologies, liturgies or rituals.  They lack compassion, mercy and forgiveness.  Doesn’t that sound like something Jesus said about the weightier matters?

Quoting Hosea is important, especially today.  But we must never think that Hosea’s verse is about Bible study, sermons or Sunday school.  We must never imagine that Hosea was telling us to get back to school, study more or earn another theological degree.  God speaks through Hosea calling His people to actionDO WHAT I SAY! That’s what it means to have knowledge.

Now we can easily see how much we know.  Just look at our actions.  Are we in conformity with God’s directions?  Do we share His concerns?  Do we follow His instructions?  As the song goes, “Make a list and check it twice.”  What do you eat?  When do you celebrate His holidays?  What do you give to His kingdom?  How do you interact with the people of His concern?  How do you treat your enemies?

By the way, just in case you haven’t carefully read the rest of this verse, did you notice the result of lack of knowledge?  The people are no longer suitable as priests.  You can’t fulfill God’s mission in the world if you aren’t living according to His direction.  You can, of course, do a lot of noble, wonderful, illuminated, altruistic work, but it won’t be useful to God.  You might win the Peace Prize or the accolades of the church, but God will have to forget you.  You see, there is only one way to be useful to God and that’s to do it His way.  That’s why knowledge is practical application.  It shows up in the way we live, move and have our being.  It’s not what’s in my head.  It’s what’s in my hands.

Topical Index:  Knowledge

Category: Today's Word  | Tags: ,  | Comments off